看完之后有点傻了,原来赤壁可以这样拍。电影到90分钟的时候我有点怀疑,这部电影到底想多长?电视剧版的三国可80多集呢!原来到最后,这是第一集。那干吗叫赤壁啊?影片拍的很多地方想法很奇特,有点不符合逻辑,但是感觉角度挺新颖。比如说小乔给周瑜缠纱布那段戏,不知道怎么两个人拍着拍着就动了情了,是想故意加一些历史人物的原始野性,还是想加点18+的内容,还是什么用意,没太看懂。林志玲在电影里给我的印象最深,对她我只有一句话:你知道你在这里干什么呢吗? 看来整部电影的喜剧因素都集中在她身上了。梁朝伟没有什么明显的破绽,扮相一开始看着有点怪,两边头发有点秃,后来看看也习惯了。演技来说还是他一贯的那一套,没什么大改变,把头套摘了,穿上西服,就成花样年华了。金城武感觉还不错,诸葛亮演的倒是不温不火,看来他逐渐能胜任大角色了。张震的孙权还是不行,台湾人说普通话,舌头还是硬,演不出孙权的霸气,看着还是卧虎藏龙里的沙漠土匪样儿。胡军的赵云太一般,戏不多,打得比较烂,大材小用了。关羽更差了,很业余的演员,看相也不行。张飞不错,演鲁智深的演员,虽然没什么词,但是说出来的几句话都还挺到位,就是赤手空拳上战场和敌人肉膊战这点戏有点太过了,不过导演让这么演,就算再不合理,你能说什么呢。赵薇戏有点多,不过还可以,不算烦人,只可惜那么厉害的点穴功在战场上也没用上,有点遗憾。国内的演员演得都还可以,很有节奏,人物刻画地也比较深,比较符合逻辑,张丰毅的曹操,算是能调动起其他演员跟着他演。尤勇的刘备戏不多,但是还算可以。日本的甘宁就太没必要了,汉语说成这样就给他用配音吧,大舌头版的中国话只有会在反映智力有问题的情况下才会用到啊!
总的来说片子可看性不强,许多情节很有争议,想法很独特新颖倒是,不错的茶余饭后调侃的对象。排兵布阵故意炫耀战法兵书的痕迹太重,有点像是给外国人拍的表现中国镇法多么神奇的意思。犯了国外溜了一圈儿的导演的通病。
最喜欢的角色是金城武的诸葛亮,最深刻印象的一句台词的是曹操手下副官再看见曹操和小乔替身的暧昧的一面时说的一句话:原来大哥发动赤壁之战是为了一个女人。


1 comment:
What a waste of time!!! I am not keen on Chinese movies especially made in Mainland China. Altough this is directed by John Wu, it is still crap. What's wrong with Honkong movies? After 1997, all the HongKong movies became unacceptably rubbish.
It's not surprising that the Red cliff is terrible from the very begining.The common fault with all the historical movies lies in one hand, the directors try to strictly follow the history, on the other hand, they attend to adapt the history with modern sense. However, either way, they will be facing critics. They will be critised as trying change history or without novelty.
Don't know why Hongkong directors have become increasingly interested in historical movies. Please those directors who do not have a bit of knowledge of Chinese history or never read those classic novels, make movies of some other kind!!! Spare your audience.
Post a Comment